Extra Extra Pizza Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Extra Extra Pizza, a celebrated gem in Buffalo, NY, at 549 W Utica St. This vibrant pizzeria specializes in thin-crust pizza inspired by NYC styles, proudly winning accolades for its delicious offerings. Each pie is crafted with love, featuring a perfectly charred crust and high-quality toppings that leave diners craving more.

Besides pizza, the menu boasts enticing appetizers like cheesy garlic bread, and a refreshing salad, providing perfect starters. To complement your meal, the extensive drink selection includes full-bodied wines and creative cocktails, perfect for a night out or a special occasion.

As you enjoy your meal, soak in the inviting atmosphere enhanced by great music and friendly staff who are eager to share their culinary knowledge. Join the local buzz and experience why Extra Extra Pizza is touted as a must-visit for any pizza lover!

Spirits Not-Pizza Our Picks Sweet Others

Spirits

White Verjus
US$7.00

Red Verjus
US$7.00

Ritual Gin
US$6.00

Ritual Tequila
US$10.00

Lyre's Italian Orange
US$6.00

Lemonade
US$4.00

Basil Lemonade
US$5.00

Bread Butter
US$4.00

Salad
US$13.00

Olives
US$8.00

Meatballs

Giardiniera
US$4.00

Cheesy Garlic Bread
US$2.00

Not-Pizza

Our Picks

Pizza Number Ii
US$22.00

Pizza Number 12
US$24.00

Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can
US$13.00

G.d. Vajra Moscato D'asti
US$26.00

Emma Off Dry Lambrusco
US$45.00

Red Tail Ridge Good Karma Riesling
US$50.00

Francoli Fernet
US$5.00

Vecchia Amaro Del Capo
US$6.00

Drink Number 5

Sweet

Others

Lagunitas Hop Water
US$4.00

Athletic Brewing
US$7.00

Phony Negroni
US$10.00

Amaro Spritz
US$10.00

Pellegrino 1l
US$8.00

Proxies Sparkling Rose
US$11.00

Unified Ferments Jasmine Kombucha
US$55.00

Proxies Pink Salt Rose

Proxies Red Ember
US$11.00

Bold Graceful: Black Cherry, Earthy
US$10.00

Dark Rich: Blackberry, Coffee
US$60.00

Drink Number 30
US$13.00

Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can
US$13.00

G.d. Vajra Moscato D'ast
US$26.00

Emma Off Dry Lambrusco
US$45.00

Walcher Amaretto
US$6.00

Vecchia Limoncino
US$4.00

Stambecco Cherry Amaro
US$6.00

Stuffed Banana Pepper
US$23.00

Chicago Beef
US$24.00

Plush Easy: Black Cherry
US$9.00

Soft Serve Ice Cream
US$6.00

Two Robbers Craft Seltzer

Anderson Valley Gose

Wayland Baby Marzen

Fiddlehead Ipa
US$8.00

Allagash White

Budweiser
US$4.00

Busch N/A

Athletic Brewing N/A

Ven Trapp Pilsner

Lagunitas Hop Water N/A
US$4.00

Talea Pink Lemonade Lager

Casa Lucciola Verdicchio De Matelica, Marche Italy

Dinamo Nucleo 2 Bianco, Trebbiano, Umbria Italy

Fabulas Cerasuolo D'abruzzo, Rose From Montepulciano, Abruzzo Italy

Tart Fizzy: #Pizzawine, Rough And Tumble

Budweiser, Busch Na

Thin Man Pils Mafia, Fiddlehead Ipa

Athletic Brewing Golden Na

Thin Man Minkey Boodle