Welcome to Extra Extra Pizza
Extra Extra Pizza, located in the heart of Buffalo, NY, is a culinary gem known for its outstanding thin-crust, NYC-style pizza. With a vibrant atmosphere and a knowledgeable staff, this eatery promises an unforgettable dining experience. Guests rave about the delicious flavors and customizable options, particularly the Sicilian-style pizzas. Pair your meal with a diverse selection of wines, making use of their popular half-off nights. The inviting decor and eclectic music create a lively vibe, inviting everyone to indulge in their unique dishes, from fresh salads to mouthwatering meatballs. At Extra Extra Pizza, every visit is a celebration of flavor and fun.
-
549 W Utica St, Buffalo, NY 14213, United States549 W Utica St, Buffalo, NY 14213, United States Hotline: +1 716-248-2994
Welcome to Extra Extra Pizza, a vibrant gem nestled in the heart of Buffalo, New York, at 549 W Utica St. With a phone number +1 716-248-2994 that rings with excitement, this eatery prides itself on offering a unique blend of traditional and artisan pizzas, all while creating a warm and inviting atmosphere.
When you step inside, you're greeted not just by delicious aromas but by an ambiance that is lively and welcoming. Patrons like Mackenzie Shuman rave about the half-off wine bottle nights, a perfect pairing to the stellar dishes. The knowledgeable staff is always ready to guide you through the menu, making your dining experience seamless and memorable. With a backdrop of great music, courtesy of Dirty WiFi, the vibe here feels like a celebration of the culinary arts.
The real stars of the show, of course, are the pizzas. Pizza Number Ii and Pizza Number 12 are must-tries, celebrated for their thin crust and perfect char that are reminiscent of NYC’s best. Each bite is a balance of flavors, crafted meticulously to please every palate. Isabel highlights how the margarita pizza delivers excellent taste despite a yearning for more cheese, indicating that even the simplest dishes shine with quality ingredients.
But pizza isn't all that's on the menu—Extra Extra Pizza also serves up a variety of delectable sides. From house-made meatballs to cheesy garlic bread and salads that surpass expectations, every dish is designed to enhance your pizza experience. Mak C found joy in pairing a refreshing white wine, "Suoli Cataldi," with their meal, proving that the drink selection complements the food beautifully.
The commitment to quality is evident not just in the food but also in how customers feel valued. With reviews praising the inviting atmosphere and the attentive service, it’s clear that Extra Extra Pizza is about more than just dining; it's about creating memories and enjoying life’s simple pleasures.
So, whether you're a local or just passing through, be sure to swing by and let Extra Extra Pizza treat you to an unforgettable meal. From pizza to wine, you'll find that this establishment is truly a staple of Buffalo’s culinary scene.
A staple in Buffalo. Half-off wine bottle nights is my favorite. But honestly any time at Extra Extra is a good time. Their staff is super knowledgeable about the pizza and wine. They have great music always playing (thank you Dirty WiFi). Decor is great. Oh, and the pizza is killer (I like to make my own Sicilian style). 5 stars for sure.
Our first trip here. Definitely coming back! Pizza is awesome and the staff was great.
I was there for a private event. I was very surprised how nice it is! They have wine and tfull bar as well as food. The food was prepared by a person who works there and it was amazing and delicious. I would imagine the food you order there is probably delicious too! Nice atmosphere, very clean and inviting. Only negative is parking is tight on the street if it's a group of people going. Know your streets and direction of the street. Well worth it to try it out! I will be going back next time looking for a place near the location!
YES! This is the pizza that Buffalo has been missing. We ordered: a bottle of white wine, "Suoli Cataldi", salad, bread with a side of red sauce, and a large pizza. This wine was described on the beverage menu as a Meyer lemon white wine, we LOVED it, especially accompanied by the pizza. Thin pizza, flour underneath just the same as NYC style pizza. There are two plaques on the wall that read (not verbatim), best NYC style inspired pizza. They won this 2 years in a row. Server was a gentleman, he explained everything well and thoroughly. No option to tip on the bill which helps me to assume their workers are treated properly. Kudos!
If you’re looking for thin crust pizza with a nice char, you need to come here! We got a margarita and although I wish there was a more cheese on it, it was absolutely delicious. The salad also exceeded my expectations and the house made meatballs were good. Great vibe of a place too!
Attended an adorable and really well run wine tasting at Extra Extra Pizza yesterday- the snack/wine pairings were top notch, the atmosphere was perfect despite being almost entirely uncultured when it comes to wine and the bathroom was SO WELL STOCKED for community needs (ibuprofen, wine wipes, mints AND diapers?! In this economy? What a gift!) The pizza involved in the wine snack plate was outrageously good and I love how they are leveraging their space to incorporate community partners. I'm going to be thinking about this brownie/dessert situation long beyond today. Can't wait to go back on a normal day!
The best pizza I've ever had. My wife took me here for my first time an hour ago. We had the pickled veggies, meatballs and a pizza with roasted garlic, sausage and mushrooms. I had a few bottles of bud (4 each) she had an amazing craft cocktail from the list of dozens. This isn't Buffalo pizza , it's not NY pizza. It's better. Perfectly cooked thin crust, fresh toppings. Totally amazing. I wanted to eat more but after 2 slices we were stuffed. The wife had a lavender ice cream cookie sandwich for dessert. As a restaurant cook I wanted to ask the chefs if the bar shared tips. I was informed that they do not accept tips. Unfortunately we misplaced some cash on the bar top.
Best Pizza in Buffalo! Perfect thin slices, if you’re looking for more Buffalo style then try the Sicilian!